Showing posts with label philosophy. Show all posts
Showing posts with label philosophy. Show all posts

13.5.08

and...

The argument against a more broad relativism (hereafter perspectivalism) charges that the argument for perspectivalism is self-refuting. This argument goes as follows:

1. Perspectivalism claims that all truth claims are subjective.
a. If a truth claim is subjective, then it is not True.
b. All Truth claims are subjective.
2. Thus, perspectivalism holds that there is no truth.
3. However, if there is no truth then perspectivalisms argument can also not be true.
4. Thus, perspectivalism is self refuting.

I believe this argument to be completely rigorous and sufficient in refuting perspectivalism. The pitfall of perspectivalisms argument is that “all truth claims are subjective.” This is false. I would hold that many truth claims are indeed true. For example, it is true that two hydrogen atoms bonded with one oxygen atom is water. This fact is true outside of any subjective interpretation. This fact is true whether or not humans even existed (though obviously there would be no proper name for hydrogen, oxygen, or water), and is thus not subjective. I will hold that I have successfully shown that perspectivalism is false. This was necessary in order to motivate that I am not of the opinion that all truth claims are relative. Instead, I hold that ethical claims are relative. The next step will then be to distinguish between an ethical claim and a truth claim and show how we can hold the former as being relative without having to admit it has the same shortcomings as the latter.

25.4.08

there is no spoon...

Preliminary thoughts:

Ethical relativism has gotten a bad wrap. Indeed stoned college students, on their latest Nietzsche binge, have ferociously preached their perspectivalism with the same logical rigor of the latest truth.com ad. In my defense of ethical relativism I wish to distance myself from said group. It will be my intention to come up with a well reasoned, and thought out argument for why ethical relativism is true. To do this I will have to argue that ethical relativism, in its most strict sense, does not fall subject to the same critiques of a more broad relativism. It will first be necessary, then, to distinguish between the two theories. Essentially, my first goal will be to reason that the argument for ethical relativism does not refute itself in the way that other forms of relativism do. This argument will rest on the distinction between a truth claim and an ethical claim. I will conclude that charging a truth claim as merely being perspectival is flimsy and offers little to no philosophical substance. On the other hand, to charge an ethical claim as being relative raises serious metaphysical and epistemological problems that cannot be ignored by philosophers of morality and ethics. The first section will thus hope to establish that one can be an ethical relativist without, to put it plainly, having to commit that “everything is perspectival.”

17.9.07

Rory and Logan

i wrote a paper when I was a junior in college called "Eros and Violence." it won an award and also sent me to a graduate conference. i just revisited it and, quite frankly, i was wrong. love isn't violent. love is banal.

i think this is why i like Rory and Logan on the gilmore girls. i know that most of you are probably Rory-Jess fanatics (and really, who wouldn't be? jess can steal powers! and he's a dreamboat captain). however, at least Rory and Logan weren't just a cheap rip off of every westernized idealization of romantic love since the beginning of time.

bring it nerds! new poll -------------->

12.9.07

zero tolerance

i fancy myself a tolerant individual. however, there are particular world views that are simply deal breakers for me. at the forefront of this brief (but distinguished) list is the belief that everything happens for a reason. now, i could accept this claim if it were to be backed by some sort of physicalist mentality like, for example, that of hard determinism. however, dear reader, i believe we both know the majority of the people who utter this statement are coming from a different background. for brevity's sake i am going to focus on two different people who may make this claim...

but first, a disclaimer: i have this blog to have fun. believe it or not, writing this is fun for me. please do not take any of the following too personally. while we may disagree on certain points it does not mean i think you are stupid, or a lesser person than me. in fact, i would love to talk about it with you sometime. however, it does mean i probably won't marry you.

person #1: the christian.

christians get a lot of shit. furthermore, they get a lot of shit they do not deserve. however, christians who believe that everything happens for a reason are simply digging their own grave. i would like to outline a few essential problems this sort of world view creates for the christian. (footnote: there are many different types of christianity. some of which the following problems i am about to go over would not have a problem with at all. i think, for our purposes, we should imagine that christian who is non-denominational and overly conservative. we will call this christian the nu-christian).

the nu-christian holds that everything that happens is a part of God's larger plan. this larger plan, of course, excludes homosexuality, rap music, women's studies and communism (these phenomena are, naturally, arosed by the devil). what this christian has failed to realize is exactly what is at stake if he/she actually holds this doctrine. the problem is that for one to accept this belief he/she ought to admit that we do not have free will. this is because if everything happens for a reason, and this reason is a part of God's predetermined plan then it is going to follow that we ourselves are determined!

quite frankly, i'm some sort of a determinist (but not the christian kind). so, this conclusion doesn't completely bother me. however, the nu-chrstian certainly does not hold himself to the rigorous problems that his own beliefs have created for himself. certainly, we cannot punish the murderer-rapist-fag-commie if he was simply acting out God's will. so, the natural move for the nu-christian is to say that the murderer-rapist-fag-commie (we will call him Scott from now on)was acting on his own accord. but what room is there in a world where everything happens for a reason for Scott's own accord? well, there isn't any room but the nu-christian has tried to respond to this apparent inconsistency.

the next move we will often hear is that there is no way for us to know what God's plan is. this, i think, is actually a clever move. this sort of attitude is also being taken up by contemporary philosophers of religion who just claim that we do not have the cognitive capacity to understand God. again, this doesn't bother me. however, there is a conflict of interest between claiming both that we do not know God's plan, and such and such is a sin. it seems to me that if we do not know God's plan than we probably know nothing of God, including what he considers a sin. finally, if we do not know anything of God then we certainly do not know whether he has a plan for us or not.

i could go on, but i am feeling a bit pretentious right now. so i am going to ask you guys how you feel about this post. please be honest as this is a deviation from my standard 2-4 sentence punch line i usually throw up on here. also, I’m not really sure who reads this or even cares. The poll to the right should help me figure out if I am just wasting time or not.

7.9.07

six theses

1. nothing makes indie kids stop dancing faster than a live band.
2. nothing makes indie kids dance harder than michael jackson (80's).
Sub-Thesis 2a. it is better to burnout than to fade away.
3. the new britney spears single is disapointing.
4. the new kanye is good.
5. some rage against the machine songs make for not-so-good dancing.
6. despite mixed reviews, my new leisure suit jacket fucking rules. (pics to come?)

26.7.07

ethics

on my commute to work this morning i heard a lively debate on the ethics of romantic love. namely, a question arose as to whether or not it was okay to send your ex-girlfriend flowers. now, before you make a hasty decision you should know that the man in question was in a relationship with another woman!

needless to say- seacrest is now my moral compass.

8.7.07

the greatest fool









when thinking about philosophers i like to think a lot about how their philosophy would change if they were alive during a different time period. for example, socrates said "the unexamined life is not worth living."



boring. no wonder why people hate philosophy. we need to upgrade. socrates 3.1 style...



"the life without degrassi: next generation is not worth living."



fixed.


4.7.07

philosopher

i just got a B.A. in philosophy. people say "i look the part"...i'm pretty sure that means i look like an asshole nobody wants to talk to.